The song '2 + 2 = 5 (Live at Hummingbird Centre)' by Radiohead reflects on themes of political dissent, societal complacency, and the suppression of truth. The title itself suggests a rejection of obvious truths for convenience or manipulation, hinting at the 'doublethink' concept from George Orwell's '1984'. Radiohead invites listeners to consider the consequences of inaction and the importance of reality and personal conviction.
The song begins in a space of contemplative criticism aimed at dreamers who may wish to correct the world's wrongs. The notion of 'home,' where 'two and two always makes a five,' represents a false sense of security built upon accepting manipulated truths—the emotional journey starts with a recognition of this societal malaise.
As the song progresses, the repeated refrain 'You have not been paying attention' serves as a direct confrontation with the listeners and a broader societal critique. It suggests that ignorance or avoidance has led to the dire situation described, an emotional crescendo of frustration and helplessness.
The bridge and outro embody a sense of inevitable capitulation to the pervasive deceit and coercion in society. Phrases like 'It's the devil's way now' and 'All hail to the thief' convey an emotional defeat, yielding to the very authority and lies being criticized earlier in the song.
The final verses evoke a sense of futility and cynicism, reinforced by the repeated declamations 'I’m not.' Despite the desire to resist, there is an acknowledgment that the struggle might be in vain—an acceptance that challenges to personal integrity and truth could be quixotic.
"Are you such a dreamer to put the world to rights? I'll stay home forever where two and two always makes a five"
This quote sarcastically addresses those who have lofty ideals to change the world but end up accepting distorted realities, represented by the mathematically incorrect statement 'two and two always makes a five'.
"January has April showers"
Likening January (typically a winter month) to April (noted for its spring showers), displays an inversion of expectations and natural order, highlighting the disconnection from reality.
"It's the devil's way now"
This line intimates that the world has succumbed to deceit and malice, likening the manipulation and control over society to the work of the devil.
"All hail to the thief"
Reference to authority being seized or maintained through deceitful means, could be a nod to the 2000 U.S. Presidential election controversy, which left many critical of George W. Bush's leadership legitimacy.