Sting's 'Englishman in New York' reflects on the experience of being a foreigner adapting to life in a different culture while maintaining personal integrity and individualism. The song encourages embracing one's uniqueness even in the face of social pressure to conform.
Initially, the listener is invited into the quaint daily customs that distinguish the protagonist as distinctly English, such as drinking tea and having toast done on one side. These simple pleasures create a sense of cultural identity that remains steadfast amidst the bustling and unfamiliar rhythms of New York City. As the protagonist walks down Fifth Avenue, there’s an air of confidence portrayed through the lyrics and the music’s steady tempo which suggests a determination to revel in one's heritage.
The chorus introduces a more introspective tone as Sting sings about being an 'alien' – a legal alien. There's a duality here: despite being legally recognized, the protagonist still feels like an outsider. The term 'alien' carries a sense of displacement evoking the emotional challenge of integration without losing self-identity. It suggests a struggle for acceptance, not by the laws of the land, but by its people and culture.
Midway through the song, the artist provides a philosophical reflection on what defines a man, using genteel traits such as manners, modesty, and sobriety to suggest that strength of character shines brightly amidst the 'night' of societal excess and bravado. The emotional journey peaks with a call for integrity, where the protagonist is counseled to 'be yourself, no matter what they say,' reinforcing the importance of self-acceptance over external validation.
The emotional journey transitions to one of guidance and wisdom as we encounter the bridge and subsequent verses that touch on what constitutes true strength and courage. By contrasting these virtues with the aggressive imagery associated with 'combat gear' and 'guns,' the song implies that the true battle is fought within – maintaining one's principles and dignity in a world quick to judge and provoke. Through repeated affirmations, the protagonist asserts his identity, empowering the listener to embrace their own uniqueness, culminating in a serene acceptance of self.
"I don't drink coffee, I'll take tea my dear"
This line emphasizes the protagonist's English identity and preference for tea, which is a cultural staple in England as opposed to the coffee culture in New York.
"I'm an Englishman in New York"
This refrain marks the protagonist's outsider status and sets the theme of cultural contrast between an Englishman and the American metropolis of New York.
"If 'manners maketh man' as someone said"
Referencing a well-known saying, this verse suggests that it’s one's behavior and character that truly define a person, rather than their outward appearance or social status.
"A gentleman will walk but never run"
This line captures the essence of restraint and dignity. It metaphorically speaks to dealing with conflicts with grace and not engaging in needless aggression or panic.